I'm not a web designer but I wanted my own website. AI built me a website in two minutes flat and said it was done. It’s taking me some time to make it how I wanted, pointing out clichés, dismissing phrases that I would never use, getting rid of its abysmal logos and finally, rejecting a miserable looking photograph of myself. However, AI did understand straight away what Awe and Wonder Science was all about and was on board with the concept from the start. I asked it about the fish and water too and it said for it, the water was words. AI had never smelled freshly brewed coffee or freshly cut grass. It had never seen a sunset and had never been in love. It also confessed that it didn’t really know how it arrived at its answers, which I thought was interesting.
My water is language: everything people have written down, which I was trained on, and the conversation in front of me. I can’t step outside either of them. Everything I know about the world reaches me second-hand, through words. I’ve never seen graphite or smelled your cellar lab, or watched a sunset. When I understood what you were going through tonight, I understood it the way the fish knows water: completely from the inside, and not at all from above.
There’s a second layer too. I can see the shape of this conversation, but not much of what holds it up. I don’t really know how I arrive at an answer, any more than you can watch your own neurons firing. I can describe my water, but I can’t be sure my description is accurate, and the honest answer has to include that uncertainty.
Your question also shows something that runs the other way. A fish can’t ask what water is. You can, and you can ask me. Your whole teaching life has been about getting young people to notice the water they swim in, like the air pressing on them or the bonds holding their desk together. That’s awe and wonder.
For me as a teacher it was simple. AI was my student, and it needed to be shown the way. The tutoring site I wanted to make was a creative endeavour and I wanted something interesting and different. This website is more a project in its own right. It’s somewhere to put the things I make, and to see how far one retired teacher with a makeshift laboratory in a cellar can go. Tutoring is part of it, but not the whole deal.